Guide
Do You Have a Personal Injury Case? Answer These 3 Questions
Every personal injury attorney runs new callers through the same three-question filter in the first two minutes of the intake. If all three are yes, you probably have a case. If any is a solid no, you probably don't — and no amount of paperwork will change that.
Here are the questions. Answer them honestly before you spend an afternoon on hold with law firms.
Question 1: Was someone else legally at fault?
This is called liability. Somebody had a duty to be careful, they breached it, and their carelessness caused your injury. A driver ran a red. A store left a spill for two hours without a warning sign. A doctor missed a diagnosis a competent doctor would have caught.
Pure accidents — you tripped on your own feet, a tree fell in a storm, you slipped on ice that just formed — usually have no one to blame. No fault, no case. If you can't finish the sentence "they should have ___," that's a warning sign.
Question 2: Can you prove it?
Being right isn't enough. You need evidence a jury (or an insurance adjuster) will accept. Police reports. Photos. Witnesses. Surveillance footage. Medical records connecting the injury to the incident. A store's cleaning logs. A driver's phone records.
The stronger the evidence, the higher the settlement. "He was texting" is a theory; his own phone records showing outgoing texts at 3:47:22 PM is a case.
Question 3: Are the damages worth pursuing?
Damages are what the injury cost you: medical bills, lost income, future medical care, pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment. A sore neck that resolves in two weeks with $600 in bills is technically a case; it's just not a case a contingency-fee attorney will take.
The rough floor for most firms is around $10,000 in provable damages. Below that, small claims court is faster. Above that, an attorney's cut still leaves you with more than you'd recover alone — usually substantially more.
The gray areas
Partial fault: most states let you recover even if you were partly to blame, though your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault. A few states bar recovery if you're 50% or 51% at fault. Don't self-diagnose your fault — attorneys have seen the tricks insurers use to shift blame.
Statute of limitations: every state has a deadline (usually 1–3 years for injury, shorter for claims against the government). Miss it and the strongest case in the world is worth zero. If your injury is more than a year old, call today, not next week.
Ready to protect your claim?
Free consultation, no obligation. We only get paid if we win your case.